I saw an interesting question on a tabletop rpg forum I look at occasionally. What do you do, as the DM, when the game slows down and your players are milling about without anything to do? How do you avoid saying, “What do you want to do now?”
Personally, I never have to say this to my players since I always give them more than enough to do. In fact, I now have all 6 of my players regularly showing to the bi-weekly tabletop rpg I’m running, so I’m getting into the problem of how I keep them from all trying to talk to me at once! I can’t exactly say this is a bad problem to have!!
But, for new DMs, what can you do to keep your tabletop rpg moving?
Character Background Stories for Tabletop RPGs
In the last 7 years of DMing (and I’ve been a DM well over 10), I haven’t had to come up with any sort of fodder to throw at my players myself. Instead, I make them provide it for me via their character background stories!
I require at least a half a page of basic info such as who their characters are and what their major goal is. My other half found googled character motivation charts and when he isn’t feeling particularly creative, he just hands in one of those to me. Good enough! I at least get the major motivations, which is fine!
However, I have a little carrot that I dangle out in front of my players. I offer 1xp per page of character background they write (normal font, no double spacing, 12 point). And because I give bonuses for well written stories, I get mini novels these days when there’s something my players really want to try mechanic wise, but don’t have enough points for! This provides me with countless hours of what my other half calls my evil DM chuckle.
Create a World that is Always on the Go
Just because the PCs decide to go to the inn for a little R&R, it doesn’t mean that the evil protagonist, lowly peasants, or other adventurers and heroes aren’t out there doing things. Governments are still going to rule over their people, kings and queens will make proclamations and declare war, and gods will continue to move in mysterious ways.
My players found out the hard way in the last pre-Vampire Darkages game I ran, that just because they couldn’t make a decision, it didn’t mean other people couldn’t. This came back and bit them in the butt more often than not.
Plot Hooks for the Win
This ties directly into creating a world that’s always on the go. Throw out those plot hooks.
I’d say about 1:5 plot hooks I throw to my players I’ve actually planned for. A lot of the time they start slowing down and stalling and some cultist, lone traveler, mage, and so on enters stage right and strikes up a conversation. In my Vampire games, my fae always have violet eyes. If I really want to stir the pot? I give my NPC violet eyes and watch the players squirm. Or sometimes I’ll just throw a chicken farmer into the plot and watch my players try to figure him out. If he’s in the game, he has to be important, right?
At any given time I’d say that there’s about 15-20 individual and group plot hooks floating around. My players are learning how to identify the urgent ones that won’t wait for the to make a decision, the ones that they can ignore and those they can put on ice until they get some time to pursue them. Regardless of what they do with the plot hook, they know that the world isn’t waiting on them to make a decision.
NPCs to Interact with the Characters
Notice how everything I’ve mention is kind of interconnected?
Since I’m running Vampire, I have a lot of NPCs that I’ve already populated the world with. However, at this point, my players have met less than a quarter. Some aren’t right for where they are in the campaign, some I created for specific plot hooks that haven’t been thrown into the mix yet or the characters haven’t gotten to. Most of them are the “hey, this would be cool” ideas that I come up with at 10 at night and jot down and flush out.
Regardless of why they’re there, I have several NPCs I can use to get my players moving. Since this is a Tremere Dark Ages game, Tremere is often the big motivator. Nobody wants to piss him off and if they get summoned to his chambers, they know they’re in deep water without a breathing device. A few of the players have contacts and allies I can use to get them going as well. Vampire is a game that really helps the DM in this regards!
Be Descriptive with your Narritives
Something I’ve noticed from Con games, usually when a DM has to ask “what are you going to do”, they weren’t descriptive enough in the scene or it wasn’t put together well. I generally run Paranoia at cons since it’s a really good system for one shot games. But, I have it easy. All I have to do is kill clones until the group decides to do something interesting. This doesn’t exactly work too well in normal campaigns.
However, when I describe a scene in detail, make sure to include obvious things for the players to do, I never have to ask them what they want to do. I may have to go to a round of players declaring what they want to do because they suddenly want to do 6 different things all at the same time, but I never have to ask them what they want to do.